The professional team at Rittgers Rittgers & Nakajima
Fact-Checked: Why Trust Rittgers Rittgers & Nakajima

What Does Your Insurance Company Owe You When Someone Makes an Injury Claim Against You?

by | Nov 18, 2026 | Personal Injury

Most people purchase liability insurance for one important reason: protection if they are accused of causing injury or harm to someone else. Whether it is auto, homeowners, or commercial liability insurance, people expect their insurance company to step in, protect their interests, and pay legitimate, covered claims.

That is what liability insurance is supposed to do.

Unfortunately, an insurance company’s financial interests do not always align with those of its policyholders. The insurance company wants to minimize what it pays, while the policyholder wants to avoid personal financial exposure and protect their assets.

At Rittgers Rittgers & Nakajima, our Cincinnati personal injury practice focuses on representing people injured by someone else’s negligence. We do not represent defendants in personal injury litigation, but we believe insurance companies should honor their obligations to the people and businesses they insure.

Here are some important things Ohio policyholders and insureds should understand when someone makes an injury claim against them.

Your Insurance Company Has a Contractual Duty to Defend and Indemnify You

Two of the most important protections provided by liability insurance are the duty to defend and the duty to indemnify.

The duty to defend means that the insurance company must provide a legal defense when a claim or lawsuit falls within the policy’s defense obligations. Generally, this means hiring and paying an attorney to defend the insured against a covered lawsuit.

That attorney should protect the insured’s legal interests by investigating the allegations, reviewing evidence, responding to the lawsuit, conducting discovery, negotiating with the injured person’s attorney, and defending the insured at trial.

The duty to indemnify is different. It means paying covered damages for which the insured becomes legally responsible, subject to the policy’s limits, exclusions, and other applicable provisions.

For example, if you cause an automobile accident and another driver is injured, your insurance company may be required to pay a settlement or judgment arising from the accident, up to the applicable policy limits.

In simple terms, defending you means providing your legal representation. Indemnifying you means paying covered claims and judgments against you.

Your Insurance Company Should Conduct a Reasonable Investigation

An insurance company should not make decisions about an injury claim based on incomplete information or assumptions. It should conduct a reasonable, objective investigation before deciding whether to accept, deny, or settle a claim.
Depending on the circumstances, that investigation may include reviewing police reports, interviewing witnesses, examining photographs and video footage, inspecting the accident location, and evaluating medical records and other evidence concerning the injured person’s damages.

The insurer should consider evidence supporting both the injured person’s allegations and the insured’s potential defenses. A claims investigation should be fair and thorough, not simply an effort to find reasons to deny the claim or minimize its value.

An inadequate investigation can result in a flawed evaluation of liability or damages and may cause the insurance company to reject a settlement opportunity that could have protected its policyholder.

Your Insurance Company Should Provide an Appropriate Legal Defense

When a covered lawsuit is filed, the insurance company generally must provide an attorney to defend the insured. The attorney’s responsibility is to provide an appropriate legal defense and protect the insured’s interests throughout the litigation. That attorney owes a duty to the insured over and above the insurance company that hired her.

Sometimes, an insurance company agrees to provide a defense while reserving the right to dispute whether the policy covers some or all of the claim. This is called a reservation of rights.

A policyholder should carefully review any reservation-of-rights letter to understand what the insurance company is agreeing to cover and what coverage issues it may later raise.

If a coverage dispute pits the interests of the insurance company against those of its insured, the insured may need independent legal advice to understand their rights and options. Some policies require the insurance company to pay for the insured’s independent attorney.

Your Insurance Company Should Make a Good-Faith Effort to Settle Valid Claims

Most personal injury claims are resolved through settlement rather than trial. A reasonable settlement can benefit everyone.

The injured person receives compensation without the expense and uncertainty of litigation. The insured avoids the risk of a potentially devastating judgment. The insurance company avoids additional defense expenses and litigation costs.
When an injured person makes a reasonable settlement demand, the insurance company should carefully evaluate the evidence, the likelihood of liability, the severity of the injuries, and the potential value of the claim.

It should not reject a reasonable settlement simply because it would prefer to pay less. This is especially important when the injured person’s damages may exceed the available insurance coverage, putting the insured at great risk financially.
For example, assume a driver has $100,000 in automobile liability coverage. Another driver suffers serious injuries, and the evidence supports a claim worth substantially more than $100,000. The injured person’s attorney offers to settle the entire claim for the available $100,000 policy limit.

If the insurance company unreasonably rejects that offer and the case proceeds to trial, the insured could face a judgment substantially exceeding the insurance coverage.

An Insurance Company Cannot Put Its Own Interests Above Those of Its Insured

Ohio law recognizes that insurance companies have a duty to act in good faith when handling claims involving their policyholders. This obligation is particularly important when the insurance company controls settlement negotiations and decides whether to accept a demand within policy limits.

An insurance company does not have to accept every settlement demand. However, it must consider the insured’s interests and cannot make settlement decisions solely to protect its own financial interests. The insurance company’s financial interests cannot take priority over the protections it promised its insured.

The insurer should consider the risk of an excess judgment, the strength of the injured person’s claim, the potential damages, and whether settlement within policy limits would protect its policyholder from unnecessary financial exposure.

What Happens If the Insurance Company Refuses to Settle and a Judgment Exceeds the Policy Limits?

Ohio law provides potential remedies when an insurance company’s bad-faith refusal to settle exposes its insured to financial liability beyond the available insurance coverage.Consider a business owner with a $500,000 liability policy. A customer suffers a serious injury, and the evidence strongly supports the customer’s claim. The injured person’s attorney offers to settle for the full $500,000 policy limit.

The insurance company rejects the offer without reasonable justification. The case proceeds to trial, and the jury awards the injured person $1 million.

The insurance company may be obligated to pay the covered judgment up to its policy limits. But the business owner may now face another $500,000 in personal financial exposure.

If the insurer acted in bad faith by unreasonably refusing the settlement opportunity, the insured may have a separate claim against the insurance company for the resulting excess loss.

The opportunity to settle may arise before a lawsuit is filed or at any point during litigation. An insurance company’s responsibility to evaluate settlement opportunities does not end when a lawsuit begins. As additional evidence becomes available, the insurer should continue considering reasonable opportunities to resolve the claim within policy limits.

What Can Policyholders Do to Protect Their Rights?

As a general rule, policyholders should promptly notify their insurance company when an accident or injury claim is made against them. Best practices include preserving relevant documents, cooperating with reasonable investigation requests, and immediately forwarding any lawsuit papers to the insurer.

They should also keep copies of communications, carefully read any reservation-of-rights letter, and ask questions about significant settlement decisions, particularly when the claim could exceed their insurance coverage.

If an insurance company refuses to provide a required defense, mishandles a claim, or unreasonably rejects a settlement opportunity, the insured may have legal remedies for breach of contract or bad faith, depending on the circumstances.
An insured who receives an excess judgment should have the insurance company’s investigation, settlement decisions, and communications carefully evaluated by an attorney familiar with Ohio insurance law.

Insurance Companies Should Honor the Protections They Promise

Liability insurance serves an important purpose. It protects individuals and businesses from potentially devastating financial consequences while providing injured people with a source of compensation. Those purposes are not mutually exclusive.

An injured person deserves fair consideration of a legitimate claim. A policyholder deserves the defense and financial protection promised by the insurance policy.

At Rittgers Rittgers & Nakajima, we proudly represent people injured by negligence throughout Cincinnati and surrounding communities. Although our practice focuses on protecting injury victims, we believe insurance companies should honor their obligations to the people and businesses they insure. Fair claims handling benefits everyone: injured people, policyholders, and the community as a whole.